EAG is your R&D partner, working with aerospace and defense manufacturers and suppliers to create faster, safer and more reliable aircraft and components. We use the most advanced…
EAG is your R&D partner, working with aerospace and defense manufacturers and suppliers to create faster, safer and more reliable aircraft and components. We use the most advanced analytical methodologies to answer complex engineering, materials and manufacturing problems, from evaluating the purity of new materials to confirming the characteristics of ceramic matrix composites. For research, development and production, we work alongside your technical staff to formulate and troubleshoot the next generation of aerospace and defense materials.
For over 50 years, EAG’s scientists have applied advanced analytical techniques to solve tough problems and support R&D activities for manufacturers and users of a wide variety…
For over 50 years, EAG’s scientists have applied advanced analytical techniques to solve tough problems and support R&D activities for manufacturers and users of a wide variety of chemicals and materials. EAG offers reliable analytical results, development support for novel products, and answers to complex problems for manufacturers of chemicals used in metals, fibers, plastics, coatings, adhesives, construction materials, textiles, lubricants and more.
Consumer products manufacturers and partners turn to EAG to answer R&D questions, ensure supply chain quality, respond to regulatory requirements and ensure well-supported legal…
Consumer products manufacturers and partners turn to EAG to answer R&D questions, ensure supply chain quality, respond to regulatory requirements and ensure well-supported legal arguments. EAG scientists have helped all types of consumer products companies accelerate innovation, resolve manufacturing concerns and comply with evolving regulations.
Drive R&D productivity and keep pace with evolving environmental regulations.
From agrochemical development to evaluating innovative packaging solutions, EAG scientists support…
Drive R&D productivity and keep pace with evolving environmental regulations.
From agrochemical development to evaluating innovative packaging solutions, EAG scientists support the agriculture/food s industry with scientific expertise required to enhance shelf life, ensure product safety and understand environmental impact. Whether in need of food quality investigations or help supporting regulatory filing of new chemicals, ask EAG. WE KNOW HOW.
When a business’s brand and reputation is at stake, clients turn to EAG’s litigation support services for dependable scientific answers. Since 1959, our scientific expertise,…
When a business’s brand and reputation is at stake, clients turn to EAG’s litigation support services for dependable scientific answers. Since 1959, our scientific expertise, testing and testimony have supported legal strategies for intellectual property, product liability and insurance cases. Our scientists offer expertise in technology, life sciences, electronics, industrial and consumer products, having tested a broad array of materials for legal challenges. We understand the unique needs of legal projects – speed, effective communication, reliability and confidentiality.
From initial concept and prototypes to verification/validation, submission and launch, EAG Laboratories is your partner in medical device development. From implant…
From initial concept and prototypes to verification/validation, submission and launch, EAG Laboratories is your partner in medical device development. From implant biocompatibility studies to surface chemistry for contact lenses, we have the experience and techniques to characterize, test and assure purity of medical devices and their materials, components, products and packaging. By utilizing our unique expertise in materials sciences, chemistry, electronics and regulatory support, EAG empowers device companies to create new ways to heal and improve patient quality of life.
Overcome R&D roadblocks with technical and regulatory know-how. For over two decades, EAG scientists have helped solve complex issues for the pharmaceutical Industry. Using…
Overcome R&D roadblocks with technical and regulatory know-how. For over two decades, EAG scientists have helped solve complex issues for the pharmaceutical Industry. Using multidisciplinary science and engineering, we help improve product development efficiency, avoid regulatory setbacks and uncover sources of problematic manufacturing issues. From GLP and cGMP studies to contaminant and packaging investigations, the scientists of EAG support every phase of the product lifecycle.
For the high-tech industry, EAG is the leader in materials characterization, surface analysis, microscopy and electronics testing. Our scientists and engineers troubleshoot and…
For the high-tech industry, EAG is the leader in materials characterization, surface analysis, microscopy and electronics testing. Our scientists and engineers troubleshoot and solve issues with consumer electronics, chip packages, printed circuit boards, displays, sensors, high-speed communications and more. We meet the demanding needs of technology innovation, enabling our clients to have confidence in their research & development, supply chains, and ultimately their manufacturing processes
When it comes to understanding the physical structure, chemical properties and composition of materials, no scientific services company offers the breadth of experience, diversity…
When it comes to understanding the physical structure, chemical properties and composition of materials, no scientific services company offers the breadth of experience, diversity of analytical techniques or technical ingenuity of EAG. From polymers to composites, thin films to superalloys—we know how to leverage materials sciences to gain a competitive edge. At EAG, we don’t just perform testing, we drive commercial success—through thoughtfully designed investigations, technically superior analyses and expert interpretation of data.
Whether connecting the internet of things, guiding surgical lasers or powering the latest smart phone, integrated circuits and microelectronics touch nearly every aspect of human…
Whether connecting the internet of things, guiding surgical lasers or powering the latest smart phone, integrated circuits and microelectronics touch nearly every aspect of human life. In the world of technology, innovation and continuous improvement are imperatives—and being able to quickly and reliably test, debug, diagnose failures and take corrective action can make the difference between a doomed product launch and building a successful global brand. EAG offers you the world’s largest and most diverse collection of specialized analytical instrumentation, capacity to perform a variety of microelectronic tests in parallel, and the multi-disciplinary expertise required to draw true insight from data.
When you need solid science and investigative engineering to address product failures, inform legal strategy, protect intellectual property or address product liability disputes,…
When you need solid science and investigative engineering to address product failures, inform legal strategy, protect intellectual property or address product liability disputes, turn to EAG. We’ve provided technical consulting, analysis and expert testimony for hundreds of cases involving the aerospace, transportation, medical device, electronics, industrial and consumer product industries. Our team of experts understands the legal process and your need for responsiveness, effective communication, scientifically defensible opinion and confidentiality. From professional consulting to data review to trial preparation and expert witness testimony, ask EAG.
Pharmaceutical & Biopharmaceutical Development Services
EAG Laboratories’ pharmaceutical development services group is now part of Eurofins Biopharma Product Testing.
Eurofins BioPharma Product Testing offers…
EAG Laboratories’ pharmaceutical development services group is now part of Eurofins Biopharma Product Testing.
Eurofins BioPharma Product Testing offers unprecedented, multi-location capacity and unmatched expertise through the largest harmonized network of bio/pharma product testing laboratories worldwide. From performing IND-enabling studies to full CMC analytical and QC support, we join your R&D team as a true partner, providing expert guidance to balance regulatory expectations with expediency and cost, and approach technical challenges with flexibility and resolve.
Having helped develop the test methods that shape current regulatory guidelines, EAG chemists, biologists and toxicologists have evaluated the environmental impact of thousands of…
Having helped develop the test methods that shape current regulatory guidelines, EAG chemists, biologists and toxicologists have evaluated the environmental impact of thousands of active ingredients and formulations—from pesticides and pharmaceuticals to industrial chemicals and consumer products. Whether you are exploring “what if” scenarios, registering a new active ingredient or formulation, responding to a data call-in or seeking to understand the latest guidance, turn to EAG for technical excellence, sound advice, GLP-compliant study execution and expert interpretation.
EAG combines biotechnology and protein characterization expertise with more than 50 years' experience analyzing chemical compounds in plant and environmental matrices to address…
EAG combines biotechnology and protein characterization expertise with more than 50 years’ experience analyzing chemical compounds in plant and environmental matrices to address the growing needs of the biotechnology crop industry. We offer a wide range of techniques required to fully characterize the event insertion and expressed proteins, as well as the various studies required to confirm the food, feed and environmental safety of products that represent the trait. From early-stage protein confirmation to GLP-compliant EDSP and allergenicity testing, we help you make faster, more informed development decisions and comply with evolving global regulations of genetically engineered crops.
No contract service provider has more experience performing custom synthesis and producing isotopically labeled compounds to support product development in life science, chemical…
No contract service provider has more experience performing custom synthesis and producing isotopically labeled compounds to support product development in life science, chemical and related industries than we do. From 14C and 3H radiolabeled clinical trial materials synthesized under cGMP, to stable-labeled active ingredients for metabolism and environmental fate/effects testing, turn to EAG. We have extensive experience with multi-step and other complex synthesis projects, and our comprehensive, in-house analytical services ensure quick turnaround of purity and structural confirmation.
Using an array of advanced separation techniques and innovative technology, we conduct highly precise analytical chromatography for various industries. Whether you want a closer…
Using an array of advanced separation techniques and innovative technology, we conduct highly precise analytical chromatography for various industries. Whether you want a closer look at the purity of your pharmaceutical or need to better understand an agrochemical’s components, EAG has the expertise to separate and evaluate any compound.
Need to evaluate the molecular structure of a compound or identify its origins? EAG knows how. With state-of-the-art tools, we can separate, vaporize and ionize the atoms and…
Need to evaluate the molecular structure of a compound or identify its origins? EAG knows how. With state-of-the-art tools, we can separate, vaporize and ionize the atoms and molecules in almost any pure or complex material to detect and obtain mass spectra of the components. We rely on decades of experience in mass spectrometry to provide our clients with precise analyses and the best detection limits.
EAG is a world leader in high-resolution imaging down to the atomic level. We offer unmatched analytical know-how, generating extremely detailed surface and near surface images…
EAG is a world leader in high-resolution imaging down to the atomic level. We offer unmatched analytical know-how, generating extremely detailed surface and near surface images for various industries, from consumer electronics to nanotechnology. Using state-of-the-art equipment and innovative techniques, we conduct expert imaging to aid in failure analysis, dimensional analysis, process characterization, particle identification and more. If you want to investigate a material with angstrom scale resolution, you can count on EAG to get the job done quickly and precisely.
EAG offers a vast array of spectroscopic techniques to clients in various industries, from defense contractors to technology pioneers. We combine unparalleled expertise and…
EAG offers a vast array of spectroscopic techniques to clients in various industries, from defense contractors to technology pioneers. We combine unparalleled expertise and methodology with cutting-edge technology to analyze your organic, inorganic, metallic and composite materials for identification, compositional, structural and contaminant information. Whether you need expert spectroscopic analysis to improve your production process or to surmount a technical challenge, EAG is up to the task.
Need to identify your unique material? Want to analyze the thermal properties of a sample, or measure the success of a process step? If it has to be done quickly and it has to be…
Need to identify your unique material? Want to analyze the thermal properties of a sample, or measure the success of a process step? If it has to be done quickly and it has to be done right, you can count on EAG. We offer a range of adaptable techniques and innovative methods to evaluate the physical and chemical characteristics of any compound. Our highly precise testing and analytical services will improve your production process, expedite R&D and help you conquer any technical challenge.
One of the most respected names in contract research and testing, EAG Laboratories is a global scientific services company operating at the intersection of science, technology and…
One of the most respected names in contract research and testing, EAG Laboratories is a global scientific services company operating at the intersection of science, technology and business. The scientists and engineers of EAG apply multi-disciplinary expertise, advanced analytical techniques and “we know how” resolve to answer complex questions that drive commerce around the world.
Science and technology transcend industry boundaries, and so does demand for EAG’s expertise. We partner with companies across a broad spectrum of high-tech, high-impact and…
Science and technology transcend industry boundaries, and so does demand for EAG’s expertise. We partner with companies across a broad spectrum of high-tech, high-impact and highly regulated industries. We help our customers innovate new and improved products, investigate manufacturing problems, perform advanced analyses to determine safety, efficacy and regulatory compliance, and protect their brands.
EAG’s corporate culture is firmly rooted in four guiding principles: “foster a growth mindset,” “find a better way,” “earn more loyal customers,” and “win…
EAG’s corporate culture is firmly rooted in four guiding principles: “foster a growth mindset,” “find a better way,” “earn more loyal customers,” and “win together.” Across all of our 20+ locations, you will find a true passion for science and the power of science to improve the world we live in. Hear what some of our ~1200 scientists, engineers and support personnel say about what it means to be part of EAG Laboratories.
EAG is growing, and we are always looking for talented, problem-solving oriented individuals to join our company. If you have a “we know how” spirit, we want to hear from you.…
EAG is growing, and we are always looking for talented, problem-solving oriented individuals to join our company. If you have a “we know how” spirit, we want to hear from you. Browse current openings now, and re-visit our careers page often.
Characterization of Polymers using Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA)
Debra Dunson, Ph.D., EAG Laboratories
Polymers respond to the energy of motion in two ways: (1) elastic response which is important for shape recovery and (2) viscous response which is essential for dispersing mechanical energy and preventing breakage. Dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) is used to study these responses, called viscoelastic properties, under conditions of low applied mechanical force.
Polymer viscoelasticity is dependent on temperature and time. Controlled heating and cooling are incorporated in DMA instruments to study temperature effects on polymer stiffness and resiliency. The test speed or time scale used for mechanically deforming the polymer enables study of time (or frequency) effects on resistance to permanent deformation. Knowledge obtained through strategic use of the three parameters of force, temperature and time provides the basis for predicting polymer performance in real world applications. Some key DMA study areas that answer the need for timely and effective characterization of polymer mechanical properties include:
Mapping the “viscoelastic spectrum”, which shows temperature (and time) dependent modulus changes from hard/rigid to soft/rubbery
Determining the glass transition temperature (Tg) of polymers
Tracking the changes in elastic (or shear) modulus as a function of frequency
Characterizing “damping” behavior: dissipation of mechanical energy through internal motion (loss modulus, tan delta)
Comparing mechanical properties of different polymers (quality, failure analysis, new material qualification)
Studying phase separation of polymer blends or copolymers
Determining effects of physical aging, crosslinking or post-cure on mechanical properties and Tg
Evaluating changes in performance imparted by inorganic fillers and/or processing additives
Time-Temperature Superpositioning (TTS): predict polymer behavior over a wider frequency or time range using a few strategic DMA tests
Transient measurements for evaluating creep, stress relaxation and stress-strain properties
This paper provides an overview of basic DMA testing and polymer case studies to demonstrate how this technique serves the need for fundamental evaluation of polymer mechanical properties.
BASICS OF DYNAMIC MECHANICAL ANALYSIS (DMA)
DMA utilizes a system of clamps for mechanical testing of solid polymeric materials. The polymer test sample must first be trimmed, cut or molded into a shape that will work with the selected clamp type. Clamp selections for polymer samples are based on giving the most suitable type of mechanical motion for the specific study type:
Shear (motion parallel to the sample surface)
Figures 1 – 4 show examples of the various clamp types.
The most suitable clamp is not only based on the preferred mechanical motion (i.e. stretch, bend, shear, etc.), it must work with the type of polymer to be tested. For example, the film tension clamp works for thin (≤2 millimeter) and flexible to semi-rigid films. However, if the film is thick or very stiff, the substitution of a flexural clamp normally gives a close approximation for tensile properties of isotropic polymer materials.
All DMA clamp configurations feature a movable clamp and one or more stationary clamps, which are used to mount the sample. The movable part applies force and displaces the sample by stretching, bending, shearing or compressing it. Some clamp types must place an initial low force on the sample before setting the clamp in motion. This keeps the sample taut (tension) or maintains contact between the movable clamp and sample (compression, 3-point bend) throughout a dynamic test.
A strain-controlled dynamic test involves programming the clamp to:
Move or “displace” the sample by a constant specified distance in a sine wave cycle (oscillation)
The oscillation continues at a specified frequency or series of frequencies
As the force moves the clamp at the specified displacement, the amplitude of the response is measured. The stress and strain responses of the material are calculated for each cycle based on the geometry and dimensions of the sample.
In force-controlled dynamic tests, the clamp movement is programmed to:
Apply a constant specified force or stress to displace the sample in a sine wave cycle (oscillation)
The oscillation continues at a specified frequency or series of frequencies
As the cyclic displacement of the material occurs at the speciﬁed force, the amplitude of the response is measured. The stress and strain responses of the material are calculated based on the geometry and dimensions of the sample.
The stress and strain values of viscoelastic materials, including polymers, are a function of temperature, time, frequency, and the applied oscillation amplitude. This is an important difference between dynamic testing and static mechanical testing. The application of a sinusoidal displacement in dynamic testing results in a sinusoidal elastic response of the material. It is not the goal to load the polymer until it breaks or falls apart. The goal of DMA is to study the elastic and viscous responses of materials in the linear viscoelastic region (LVR), which means under low force conditions that do not destroy the structure.
DMA is used to determine which conditions change the “original” viscoelastic behavior of the sample, and possibly lead to small irreversible deformation of the original structure. An example is a temperature sweep DMA test, which monitors modulus as a function of increasing temperature. As a thermoplastic polymer is heated, it will eventually undergo a phase transition where original elasticity is lost and the polymer becomes ﬂuid and deforms irreversibly.
This is known as the glass transition temperature (Tg), and in DMA, this state is where the viscous response predominates. The low force ensures that Tg is a measurable part of the viscoelastic spectrum because the deformations within the material are on the order of micrometers. Therefore, the material is not pulled apart or squeezed out by the clamps during the measurement.
Figure 5. Diagram Representing DMA Oscillatory Input and Response
Figure 5 shows a simple illustration of a hypothetical sinusoidal strain input to the sample (blue curve) and the sinusoidal stress response measured by the DMA instrument (red curve). The dotted lines show that the stress response of the material is out of phase with the strain input, which is the behavior exhibited by viscoelastic materials. The degree to which it is out of phase is known as the “phase angle”, denoted by the Greek letter delta (δ).
The relationship of stress and strain depends on the phase angle, which is a function of how much the polymer response lags behind the strain input. This relationship is used to derive trigonometric equations that produce three quantiﬁable properties that describe the sample response under the applied testing conditions.
E’= STORAGE MODULUS
E”= LOSS MODULUS
E”/ E’= TAN δ
When the sample is tested in shear mode, the storage and loss modulus are denoted as G’ and G”, respectively. And tan δ becomes G”/G’.
Storage modulus corresponds to the mechanical energy stored by the material during a loading cycle. Consequently, the storage modulus is related to the stiffness and shape recovery of the polymer during loading. The loss modulus represents the damping behavior, which indicates the polymer’s ability to disperse mechanical energy through internal molecular motions.
Tan delta is a sensitive indicator of the thermal/mechanical conditions that cause significant bond rotation or intermolecular friction and flow.
DMA CASE STUDIES OF POLYMERIC MATERIALS
As discussed above, dynamic testing utilizes low forces to ensure that the polymer structure is not destroyed while measuring viscoelastic properties. Consequently, the first step in analyzing a polymer sample is to determine the force or amplitude range that works within the linear viscoelastic region (LvR) of the material. To find the LvR, a test called an amplitude sweep is performed in which the sample is oscillated through a range of strain or stress amplitudes (at constant temperature). The goal is to find the amplitude range that corresponds to the desired “linear response” which means that the modulus measurement is the same regardless of the strain (or stress) amplitude. Figure 6 shows data acquired for a polymer specimen during an amplitude sweep at 1 Hz (frequency) and 25°C. The LvR in this case is between 30 and 65 μm (slope ≈ 0). An amplitude value within this range must be chosen when setting up tests to measure the modulus and tan delta of these specimens.
Figure 6. Amplitude Sweep Data for Polymer Specimen at 1 Hz and 25°C
Figure 7. Storage Modulus (E’) of Three Different Polymers
VISCOELASTIC PROPERTIES AS A FUNCTION OF TEMPERATURE
DMA is a sensitive technique for studying how the viscoelastic properties of polymers change as a function of thermal environment. If the same frequency is used for the oscillation cycle, a meaningful comparison can be made between different materials under identical thermal conditions. For example, Figure 7 compares the storage modulus (E’) curves for three different polymers that were obtained using a heating ramp rate of 3°C /minute and an oscillation frequency of 1 Hz. The relatively flat regions at the lower temperatures correspond to the glassy (rigid) state of each polymer. The polymer glass transition (Tg) starts where the curves initially bend downward. Beyond this point, the polystyrene and polycarbonate curves show a steep drop off (rapid decrease in modulus), which results from significant softening and rubbery flow. The polyethylene terephthalate (PET), which contains crystalline structure, shows a much more gradual modulus decrease after the onset of Tg. The crystallites in PET act as physical crosslinks, which toughen the material and give a higher storage modulus below and above Tg. This example shows that DMA is a relatively simple technique for comparing the modulus and Tg of polymers, which can assist with design, processing and applications.
Figure 8. Storage Modulus (E’) and Tan Delta of Two Different Polymers
DMA storage modulus plots can be used to calculate the Tg onset temperature of a given polymer. This is done using the graphical intersection of two lines drawn tangent to the E’ curve. First, a tangent is drawn along a selected part of the curve before the transition. Then a second tangent is drawn from the inflection point of the curve to the approximate midpoint of the modulus drop. Two examples are shown in Figure 8 (black curve for polyvinyl chloride and green curve for polycarbonate). However, it is normally preferred to calculate Tg using the peak maximum in the tan delta plot (Figure 8 – red curve for polyvinyl chloride and blue curve for polycarbonate). The reason is that accurate placement of the tangents is subject to more uncertainty compared to accurately defining the apex of a peak.
Figure 9. Loss Modulus (E”) and Tan Delta of Polycarbonate (PC) and Crosslinked Polystyrene (PS)
The Tg temperatures calculated by E’ tangent and tan delta methods for a specific polymer are not identical. This emphasizes the fact that polymer glass transitions occur over a temperature range (not at a single temperature). When setting design and processing parameters for specific polymers, it is important to know the temperature where segmental molecular motion begins. The DMA loss modulus, E”, is very useful in this respect because it is a measure of the viscous nature of polymeric materials. The peak maximum of E” corresponds to the beginning of significant segmental motion of the polymer chains. Thus, the mechanical energy input is dispersed as heat by the internal friction caused by chain motion, which characterizes the phenomenon called damping. By comparison, the tan delta peak, which is usually reported in the literature for Tg, best represents longer-range cooperative molecular motion which is consistent with rubbery flow, permanent deformation or both depending on molecular structure. Figure 9 shows a plot overlay, which compares the loss modulus (E”) and tan delta of two different polymers: polystyrene and polycarbonate.
Figure 10. Loss Modulus (E”) of Failed and Good Elastomer Materials
Loss modulus (E”) is a sensitive indicator of molecular differences and has proved very useful in failure investigations. The plot in Figure 10 shows an overlay of E” curves of a failed elastomer and two controls of the same material. In this case, Polymer 2 was suspected of causing mechanical failure in a medical device. Polymers 1 and 3 represented the “good” controls, which met design specification and passed field tests, respectively. The E” peak maximum of Polymer 2 was significantly lower (-43°C) compared to the controls. The peak was also broader for Polymer 2. Consequently, Polymer 2 showed less resistance to motion at the onset of Tg, which strongly suggested a “looser” internal structure and/or the presence of plasticizers that led to larger rotational freedom. This higher “viscous” response was a strong indicator that the molecular structure of Polymer 2 lacked the resiliency of Polymers 1 and 3, which is the property needed for recovering shape after mechanical stress is applied.
VISCOELASTIC PROPERTIES AS A FUNCTION OF FREQUENCY
The case studies above demonstrated the effect of temperature on properties measured by DMA. A further consideration is the effect of changing the frequency of the applied sine wave cycle during the test. The rate of motion of the polymer chains not only depends on the thermal environment, it is also affected by the frequency of loading. When holding the amplitude constant and increasing the frequency of the applied deformation, the molecular relaxations (e.g. E” and tanδpeak max) are observed at higher temperatures. This information is important for materials used in applications where exposure to multiple frequencies and operating temperatures is common, such as in mechanical belt drive systems.
Figure 11. DMA Curve Overlay for Oriented PET Film Tested at Four Frequencies
Figure 11 illustrates the frequency dependence of the storage modulus (E’) and tan delta of an oriented PET film. The Tg was calculated from the peak maximum in tan delta at each frequency (0.1, 1, 5 and 10 Hz). The difference in Tg measured at 10 Hz and 0.1 Hz was 12°C.
Another feature of DMA is the application called Time-Temperature Superposition (TTS). This technique is commonly used to predict viscoelastic behavior over a longer time or frequency range than can be conveniently measured in a testing lab. For example, consider the storage modulus of PET film measured at eight different frequencies in a frequency sweep under conditions of stepwise increase in temperature. The resulting data (shown in Figure 12) can be used to generate a master curve for predicting the storage modulus at frequencies beyond he testing limits. To do so, a single reference temperature is selected from the data (e.g. 95°C) and the storage modulus (E’) values at this temperature for each frequency in the series (e.g. 20, 10, 5, 2, 1, 0.5, 0.2, 0.1 Hz) are constructed into a “reference data set” of E’ versus frequency. Then TTS mathematical processing is used to superimpose the remaining data sets onto the reference data, which constructs a master curve of (theoretical) storage modulus versus frequency. Figure 13 shows the master curve (in blue) and the unshifted data (in red), which are overlaid to illustrate the results obtained for the PET case study. As shown, the master curve projects the PET storage modulus over a dramatically wider frequency range than used for the experiment.
Figure 12. Storage Modulus (E’) vs Frequency for Stepwise Increase in Temperature (range 34.9 – 159°C)
Figure 13. TTS Master Curve of Storage Modulus (E’) vs Frequency Overlaid with “Unshifted” Curves (red)
Although the preceding discussion of TTS was very simplified, the basic principles governing the technique are summarized by the following statements:
Viscoelastic polymers have a special relationship between time (frequency) and temperature. Polymers relax or stiffen as a function of the thermal environment. They also relax or stiffen as a function of time.
TTS takes advantage of this time-temperature “equivalency.” Viscoelastic properties change in the same manner at high temperatures as for long time periods (low frequency), and the properties change in the same manner at low temperatures as for short time periods (high frequency).
TRANSIENT EXPERIMENTS: CREEP AND STRESS RELAXATION TESTS BY DMA
Most standard DMA instruments are equipped to perform transient experiments, which involve applying a load to the specimen and monitoring its response over a specified time period. Two types of transient tests are used to study the viscoelastic response of polymers:
Creep Test: a polymer specimen is subjected to a fixed load and the change in dimension is monitored as a function of time.
Stress Relaxation Test: a polymer specimen is loaded to deform it by a fixed amount and the change in load to maintain that deformation is monitored as a function of time.
Figure 14. DMA Creep Test Graph Showing Creep and Recovery Curves
Creep testing is useful for measuring the amount of recoverable and non-recoverable strain after rapid and complete removal of the applied load. The recoverable strain depends on the elasticity of the polymer and the time scale of the experiment (as well as the thermal environment). Under isothermal conditions, the time dependency of viscoelastic response implies that the best approach is to apply the load until the material reaches a steady state, followed by instantaneous release of the load and allowing sufficient recovery time for the sample to reach a steady state. Figure 14 shows a graph of creep and recovery behavior of a polymeric material as a function of time. Activation of the instantaneous load on the material is represented by the steep linear portion of the curve at time ~ 0. The creep at load is shown over a 5 minute period (purple curve – creep zone). After subsequent release of the load, the strain in the material recovered for ≈ 9 minutes (red curve – recovery zone). As shown, the polymer recovery had nearly reached steady state by the end of the experiment. Ideally, the recovery period should be extended until the slope is zero, which allows comparison of the ultimate recoverable and non-recoverable strain in the material.
Under isothermal conditions, application of a constant strain to a viscoelastic material will result in gradual loss of mechanical resiliency due to molecular relaxation. Therefore, it requires gradually lower force over time to maintain the strain at the fixed level. This property is called stress relaxation. Unlike creep in which the strain (dimension change) is monitored, a stress relaxation test tracks the decrease in stress under constant deformation. Stress relaxation is important when polymeric parts are used to form a mechanical joint or seal, such as plastic compression fit fasteners and rubber flange gaskets. In such applications, it is important that the stresses induced by the connection do not result in loosening of the fitting. Stress relaxation experiments are designed to predict the loss of mechanical properties as a function of time, which is essential knowledge for material development and mechanical design.
Figure 15. DMA Stress Relaxation Graph Showing Stress and Strain versus Time
Stress relaxation of polymers depends on temperature and the magnitude of the applied deformation (strain), as well as the time period of the test. Figure 15 shows the stress relaxation curve for a polypropylene sample subjected to a 1% strain in cantilever bending mode at 25°C. The flexural modulus was also calculated from the data (as plotted in Figure 16), which illustrates the decline in material stiffness over time. The plot shows that the flex modulus of polypropylene decreased by 110MPa over ≈22 minutes under the 1% strain.
Creep and stress relaxation properties are vital to material and engineering design because they are related to polymer molecular structure and associated chemistries in the formulation. The chemical aspects of polymer formulations affecting mechanical performance and design include:
Polymer molecular weight (distribution)
Plasticizers / slip agents
Crosslinking (degree and type of)
Orientation / alignment
Chain stiffness (single vs. double bonds, aliphatic vs. aromatic)
Pendant groups / branching on polymer chains
Interaction with small molecules (e.g. moisture or residual monomers)
Impurities, defects, inclusions
Chemical and physical aging (e.g. oxidation or degradation)
The demand for fast turnaround in design of new polymeric devices and materials necessitates quick completion of associated laboratory tests, which include mechanical characterization. Consequently, it would not be practical to perform multiple creep experiments on Polymer A using many different temperatures and time conditions. It certainly would be impracticable to compare Polymer A with a glass-fiber modified version of Polymer A in multiple temperature / time experiments. Fortunately, TTS can be applied to transient experiments for projecting long-term behavior using a few strategic experiments. Molecular relaxation and reorganization are gradual processes at low temperatures, but speed up significantly at higher temperatures. Therefore, relatively short-term experiments can be conducted at higher temperatures, after which TTS is applied to shift the experimental curves along the time axis. The resulting master curve extrapolates the data to predict the viscoelastic responses at longer time periods, which were not possible to measure experimentally.
An example TTS data manipulation is presented on the following page, which is based on data obtained under low shear stress using a mechanical analyzer equipped with a rotational rheometer. Although the equipment is not identical to DMA, which operates in linear mode on solid materials, the process of shifting the data is performed in exactly the same manner for both rheometer and DMA creep experiments.
The example creep results were obtained for polystyrene using an applied shear stress for 10 minute periods (600 seconds) at five different temperatures (110, 120, 140, 160 and 180°C). Figure 17 shows an overlay of the data for the five experiments: creep compliance [J(t)] versus time. Creep compliance has units of m2/N and is defined as J(t)=Strain/(Shear stress). The creep compliance at 140°C was selected as a reference curve, and TTS was used to shift the remaining four curves to the left and right of the reference curve. The master curve is shown in Figure 18, which is a log – log plot of creep compliance [J(t)] versus time. The scaling on the log time axis is seconds. The master curve shows predictive compliance data that extends the time axis up to 105 seconds. This allows prediction of long term creep behavior at the chosen reference temperature (140°C in this example). A time saving feature is the ability to select another temperature in the range used for the test and create a predictive master curve for the new temperature selection. This illustrates how TTS can save time and resources while projecting viscoelastic properties onto a longer time scale.
Figure 17. Overlay of Creep Compliance Curves: Polystyrene at Five Temperatures
Figure 18. TTS Master Curve Generated from Polystyrene Creep Curves
The above cases represent just an overview of the capabilities of DMA and how this tool provides rapid characterization of viscoelastic properties of polymeric materials. It should be mentioned that DMA often proves to be the most sensitive of the thermal analysis techniques for comparing properties and often serves as the best thermal analytical tool for failure analysis. Please contact EAG Laboratories for further information on using DMA for your polymer needs.
Access Our Resources
To enable certain features and improve your experience with us, this site stores cookies on your computer.
Please click Continue to provide your authorization and permanently remove this message.